| 07/27/45 | Baker, Ralph |
| 12/19/45 | Garman, Ronald |
| 12/19/45 | Huber, Henry |
| 10/18/46 | Garman, Jerry |
| 01/21/46 | Updegraff, Dale |
| 12/09/48 | Sheaffer, Melvin |
| 09/13/49 | Snavely, Jack |
| 08/21/63 | Litzenberger, Raymond |
| 11/20/63 | Beaver, James |
| 11/20/63 | Derstine, James |
| 12/16/64 | Wadlinger, Melvin |
| 04/21/65 | Michaels, Stephen |
| 08/21/68 | Wadlinger, John |
| 11/08/79 | Marshall, Edward * |
| 03/28/80 | Rudy, Michael * |
| 10/25/83 | Wiseman, Jeffery * |
| 06/20/87 | Gainor, Matthew |
| 07/18/88 | McMichael, Richard |
| 10/15/90 | Kutzelman, Scott |
| 08/29/94 | O’Marr, Greggory |
| 08/17/95 | Bohr, Mark |
| 09/12/95 | Emrick, Ryan |
| 06/24/96 | Hackenberger, Jeff |
| 03/23/97 | Jones, Michael |
| 10/13/99 | Rudy, William |
| 11/10/02 | Hoffman, III, Charles |
| 05/13/03 | Rott, Brian |
| 02/15/04 | Bowers, Richard |
| 10/01/04 | Epply, Troy |
| 06/23/04 | Bittinger, Christopher |
| 01/18/05 | Debroisse, Patrick |
| 10/27/05 | Brothers, Kevin |
| 03/02/05 | Hannawalt, Jeremy |
| 03/20/07 | Hoffman, Justin |
| 10/23/08 | Fetrow, Ryan |
| 03/27/08 | Gilbert, Cody |
| 03/12/10 | Deverter, Trent |
| 11/23/10 | Shiery, Joshua |
| 01/20/11 | Owen, Patrick |
| 07/23/12 | Fake, Corey |
| 09/10/12 | Mrksic, Nick |
| 08/19/13 | Dove,Alec |
| 08/28/13 | Balvanz, Justin |
| 12/27/13 | Holley, Caleb |
| 01/20/14 | Mrksic, Dylan |
| 02/24/14 | Abbott, Jake |
| 06/09/14 | Campbell, Benton |
| 09/15/14 | Shiery, Caleb |
| 09/25/16 | Foy, Kyle |
| 10/08/17 | DeMarchis, Nicholas |
*Indicates when Troop 89 was known as Troop 889